|
Bolling v. Sharpe,
347 U.S.
497 (1954)
Author: Sam Biers
Facts: Petitioners are
minor African Am. students who were refused admission to a public school, in
District of Columbia, attended by white children solely b/c of their race.
Issue(s): Whether the Due
Process Cl of the 5th imposes a correlating duty on the federal govt
to prevent racial segregation in the public school within its jurisdiction?
Holding: racial segregation
in the public schools of the District of Columbia is a denial of the due process
of law guaranteed by the 5th.
Procedure: Petitioner’s
sought relief in D.Ct for D. of Columbia. That court dismissed their
complaint. U.S.S.Ct granted certiorari before the Ct App judgment was issued
b/c of the importance of the question presented. Case will be restored to the
docket for reargument on other questions presented.
Rule(s): 5th
Amend
Rationale: The Fifth
Amendment is applicable to the D of Columbia, but it does not include an equal
protection clause as the 14th Amendment. The 14th only
applies to the states. But the concepts of equal protection and due process are
not mutually exclusive. EP CL is a more explicit safeguard of prohibited
unfairness than DP, and thus the Ct will not imply that the two are always
interchangeable. Yet, discrimination has been held by this Court to be so
unjustifiable as to be violative of DP.
The Const forbids,
regarding civil and political rights, discrimination by the general govt or the
states, against a citizen on the basis of their race. Furthermore, denial of
the right to convey property by the owner according to a law is considered
unreasonable, and a denial of DP.
Where the Const bars state
govt from maintaining racially segregated schools, the same Const imposes a
similar duty on the federal govt.
|