The Law School Authority

TICKLE v. BARTON Case Brief

Summary of TICKLE v. BARTON
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, 1956.
142 W. Va. 188, 95 S.E.2d 427

Cause of Action: Tickle (P) sues both Barton and Coleman (D’s) to recover damages for personal injuries caused by a motor vehicle.

Facts: Motor vehicle was owned by Barton and operated by Coleman.  P claims injuries were caused by D’s negligence.  D challenges validity of being served b/c P’s attorney tricked him into being at a certain place within McDowell County.

Issue: Does this court have jurisdiction over the D even though he was tricked into being served?

Rule:  “Where service of process is procured by fraud, that fact may be shown, and, if shown seasonably, the court will refuse to exercise its jurisdiction and turn the P out of court.”

Application: B/c Barton was procured by trickery, his service was found to be null and void.

Conclusion:  The Circuit Court of McDowell County does not exercise jurisdiction over the D.



Copyright © 2001-2012 4LawSchool.com. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy HotChalk Partner