|
Title:
Gold v. Salem Lutheran Home Association,
Cal, 1959.
Author: Marie
Plaintiff:
Executive of deceaseds estate.
Facts: -84-year-old Mr. Gold wanted
to be a resident in life care home.
-He moved into home on Aug. 1st as probationary period
and paid for Aug. and Sep.
-Board of directors to have a meeting to determine Ps
eligibility for staying there.
-Resident and board signed contract and he pre-paid the fee, he
then died of stroke.
Procedure: -Ct below, at trial
without jury, ruled in favor of Defendant, Luthern Home.
-Relatives appeal.
Issues: I. When did the contract in
this case begin?
II. Can heirs of deceased recover damages under unjust enrichment
theory when the contract had not yet gone into effect?
Holding: I. The contract begins when
the two parties signed the contract.
II.
Heirs of deceased cannot recover damages under unjust enrichment
theory when the contract had not yet gone into effect.
Ruling: Judgment of lower court is
affirmed; ruled in favor of defendant.
Rationale: -Plaintiff and Defendant
entered into contract with certain assumptions. P is guaranteed
place to live until he died.
-Plaintiffs death was reasonably foreseeable.
-Plaintiff received a benefit for his money: peace of mind, place
to stay.
Evaluation: -Dissent - Justice
Peters. Implied condition?
-Broad rule from this case that applies to all cases - contract
begins when it is executed between the two parties. They know the
risks they are taking. Once you have signed, youve agreed
to something and youre bound.
|