Byram v. Main Case Brief

Summary of Byram v. Main (1987), 523 A.2d 1387 (Me. 1987)

Parties: Appellee – Plaintiff – Byram

Appellant – Defendant – Main

Court: Court of Appeals, Maine, 1987

Facts: Main’s daughter’s pet donkey, Meadow, escaped from its enclosure and ventured onto I-95 where Byram’s tractor-trailer collided with it and caused injuries and damages.

Procedural Posture: TC – held Main was strictly liable for damages created by his donkey.

Issue: Is the owner of a domesticated animal that escapes unknown to the owner held strictly liable for damages and injuries to the plaintiff?

Judgment: Vacated and remanded to TC for judgment to the Defendant.

Holding: The court held that the owner should be only held to a negligence claim for letting his donkey to escape and venture onto a highway. It is up to public policy makers to decide through statute to hold them more liable.


Rule: Owner’s of domesticate animals that do not trespass are only held to levels of negligence.

Copyright © 2001-2012 All rights reserved. Privacy Policy HotChalk Partner